Cal-Mag Compared: Drip Hydro vs Sensi vs Botanicare vs Canna vs CALiMAGic, Price per Gallon of Concentrate
Cal-Mag Compared: Drip Hydro vs Sensi vs Botanicare vs Canna vs CALiMAGic, Price per Gallon of Concentrate
Cal-Mag products look alike on the shelf, and the prices swing a lot by size. Before you pick one, line them up on a common unit: dollars per gallon of concentrate.
This guide compares the five liquid Cal-Mag products in our catalog by size and price. If you are buying because a plant looks off, start with our deficiency diagnosis guide, because Cal-Mag only fixes the right problem.
The 30-Second Answer
Cheapest per gallon of concentrate: Drip Hydro 5 gallon at $20.00, then Sensi 23 L at about $20.55 and Botanicare 5 gallon at $22.00. Most expensive: GH CALiMAGic and Canna, at roughly $29 to $33 a gallon. The catch: strengths differ, and only Canna's listing gives a feed rate, 2 to 4 ml per gallon. At that rate Canna costs about 1.5 to 3.5 cents per gallon of feed.
Price by Size
| Product | Sizes, price, and price per gallon of concentrate |
|---|---|
| Drip Hydro CaMg | Quart: $10.82 ($43.28/gal) Gallon: $27.05 ($27.05/gal) 5 gal: $99.99 ($20.00/gal) |
| Sensi Cal Mag Xtra | 1 L: $10.40 ($39.37/gal) 4 L*: $29.49 ($27.91/gal) 23 L: $124.87 ($20.55/gal) |
| Botanicare Cal-Mag Plus | Quart: $14.99 ($59.96/gal) Gallon: $34.99 ($34.99/gal) 2.5 gal: $69.99 ($28.00/gal) 5 gal: $109.99 ($22.00/gal) |
| Canna CalMag Agent | 1 L*: $14.94 ($56.55/gal) 5 L: $44.02 ($33.33/gal) 10 L: $81.48 ($30.84/gal) 20 L: $154.80 ($29.30/gal) |
| GH CALiMAGic | Quart*: $17.31 ($69.24/gal) Gallon: $32.70 ($32.70/gal) 2.5 gal: $80.24 ($32.10/gal) |
* Out of stock at the time of writing.
Bigger sizes save money on every brand, though only slightly on GH CALiMAGic ($32.70 a gallon in the 1 gallon, $32.10 in the 2.5). Drip Hydro drops from $43.28 a gallon in the quart to $20.00 in the 5 gallon, and Sensi falls to about $20.55 in the 23 L. Quarts and 1 L bottles cost about twice as much or more per gallon than the big sizes, so they are for testing, not for running a room.
What We Can and Can't Say About Strength
The Canna CalMag Agent listing says 2 to 4 ml per gallon of solution, and says it is for calcium-sensitive systems like reverse osmosis water with coco. If you are on Canna, our Canna Coco feed chart guide shows where it fits. The Drip Hydro, Sensi, Botanicare, and CALiMAGic listings describe what the products do but don't give a feed rate or an analysis in our catalog, so we can't compare cost per gallon of feed. Check the label for each before you decide.
A Dry Option
If you inject and want calcium without the liquid price, we also carry YaraLiva Calcium Nitrate 15.5-0-0 in a 50 pound bag at $43.25, about 87 cents a pound. It supplies calcium and nitrogen and no magnesium, so it is a different product, not a swap.
Start the conversation
Send your water source, medium, and nutrient line. Email info@modernfarms.store or call 818-504-8165, and we will tell you which Cal-Mag fits, including when you don't need one.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cal-Mag the same as calcium nitrate?
No. Calcium nitrate, like the YaraLiva we carry, is a dry fertilizer that supplies calcium and nitrogen. Cal-Mag products are liquid supplements that supply calcium and magnesium, and some add iron or trace minerals, per their listings.
Which Cal-Mag is cheapest?
Per gallon of concentrate, the Drip Hydro 5 gallon at $20.00 and the Sensi 23 L at about $20.55 lead, with the Botanicare 5 gallon at $22.00. But the products are not the same strength, and only Canna's listing gives a feed rate, so concentrate price is not the cost of using it.
How much does Canna CalMag Agent cost to use?
Canna's listing gives 2 to 4 ml per gallon of finished nutrient solution. At that rate the 20 L at $154.80 works out to about 1.5 to 3.1 cents per gallon, and the 5 L at $44.02 about 1.8 to 3.5 cents per gallon.
Why does my plant still show a deficiency after adding Cal-Mag?
Many things can look like a calcium or magnesium deficiency, including pH that is too far off and water that is already hard. Our deficiency guide walks through how to tell them apart.
Do I need Cal-Mag with coco?
Canna's listing says CalMag Agent is for calcium-sensitive systems, particularly reverse osmosis water with coco. Other lines may differ, so check your nutrient maker's chart.
Why isn't the GH 6 gallon in the table?
It is priced above the 1 gallon per gallon, which is unusual, and we want to confirm that before printing it.
Do you finance equipment?
For licensed facilities, projects over $25,000. Nutrients aren't usually part of those, so ask us in writing.
This article is general information, not agronomic, financial, or legal advice. Price per gallon of concentrate is calculated from displayed prices and doesn't account for differences in strength. The Canna feed rate comes from its listing. Prices and stock reflect ModernFarms' live catalog as of November 3, 2026. We don't upsell, and we'd rather you buy the size you will use than the biggest jug.
